Can You Trust Your Life to a Computer?

No Comment

The first batches of Tesla’s first “car that everyone can buy”, the model 3, was recently released. With over 450,000 preorders, Tesla’s claim seems to be holding up. This many new Teslas on the road comes with more than just the environmental benefits that electric cars bring, there will now be over 450,000 cars on the road with the ability to drive on autopilot.

So what does this mean for every else? Should we trust a computer with human lives? Are self-driving cars better than human drivers? Should self-driving cars be the norm?

Photo via Tesla.com

To start to answer these questions, we should first look at the numbers. After Tesla’s current autopilot system was introduced Tesla’s crash rate dropped ~40% according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. So that’s it right? Autopilot is simply better than humans and we should all convert to autopilot right now. Well, not quite. Very few miles have been driven, so the sample size is too small to have any conclusive results about whether self-driving cars are safer than traditional cars. However, the small sample size does not mean that these results are completely useless. If anything, they confirm that autopilot is at least as safe as human drivers, so autopilot can be very promising for the future of self-driving cars.

So then, should we start moving to self-driving cars as the norm in the near future once Tesla can collect more autopilot data? Maybe, but probably not. Although Tesla’s autopilot does lower the crash rate, there are still crashes, so the current technology far from perfection. Tesla recognizes this imperfection of their autopilot software, and states that “autopilot is intended for use only with a fully attentive driver”. Until there can be a 100% guarantee that a self-driving car will not crash unless there is no other option, autopilot should not be solely responsible for the control of a car.

Nonetheless, self-driving technology has come very far, and a 40% reduction in crash rate is no small feat. As it stands today, Tesla’s autopilot technology is ready for mass use at a safety level where I would personally feel comfortable driving with it. Still, it has some steps to go before drivers can start to rely solely on autopilot.

Featured Image: https://www.tesla.com/model3

About the author

Luc Coté is a 16 year old Junior at St. Mark’s School. In his free time Luc enjoys coding, building things, politics, and grilling. Luc is a self-proclaimed grill master, a member of Students for Sustainability, an enthusiastic Peer Tutor, and co-founder of the Young Independents club. Luc hopes to soon start a Coding Club at St. Mark’s as well. Academically, Luc is an involved and passionate student with interests in Computer Science, Math, Physics, Engineering, and History. Luc joined the Parkman Post to combine his enjoyment of politics with his love for STEM.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked (required)

Also in this Issue

How Partisan Politics are Shaping the Future Through Education

It’s not a national secret that the quality of public education is unequal across the United States. While the U.S. Department of Education directs federal financial aid, collects data on American schools, and advocates for equal access to education across the nation, the federal government only provides for about 8 percent of the total capital spent on education every year, making states responsible for the majority of financing. Read more →

Howdy’s Homemade Ice Cream: A Store Making a Difference

Tom Landis' "Howdy Homemade Ice Cream" in University Park, Texas is famous for not only their friendly customer service but also their best employees. The entire store and process was created to accommodate people with different abilities. For example, the cash register only accepts bills, simplifying the process of different transactions. Read more →

“Two in Four People are Jewish”

“Two in four people in Brooklyn are Jewish”; that is not a definite fact, but it’s a figure of speech my grandmother claims to be true. She repeats this phrase as a hope, as a reminder, as a prayer, as if in some way saying it makes it true. Read more →